
timum
design and course of action can
only be decided on after study and con-
sultation among experts in a number of
fields.
The nominal values for the first
model colony are taken as: construc-
tion force, 2000 people; population,
10 000; total mass, 500 000 tons. When
the design and cost analysis are done in
detail for the entire enterprise, the need
to fit a budget may force some reduc-
tion in size. The initial estimates have
been aimed at holding the cost equal to
that of one project we have already car-
ried through: Apollo. The choice of
10 000 as a target population ensures
that, even with some reduction, Model 1
will be large enough to obtain econo-
mies of scale and to serve as an effective
industrial base for the construction of
Model 2. A much reduced colonization
project would be little more than a re-
named space station, perhaps able to
maintain itself but incapable of build-
ing the larger models that are necessary
if the program is ultimately to support
itself.
It is an essential feature of the
colonization project that Earth should
no longer have to support it after the
first two or three stages.
Ultimately, colonization could take
place in the entire sphere, 3 X 10
17
km
2
in area, that surrounds the Sun at the
distance we have evolved to prefer (the
so-called "Dyson sphere"). For the
Rotary pellet launcher
The
rotary launcher
is
assumed
to be a
symmetric two-arm propeller-like
device,
running
at
constant
speed,
with launching
arms
of
ten-meter
radius.
Mass
Rotation rate
Tip
speed
(escape velocity)
Power
10 tons
2300 rpm
2400
m/sec
1600
horsepower
The
transfer rate
per
launcher
is
3250
tons
per
year
for the
transfer
of 5-gm
pel-
lets,
assuming
a 25%
duty
cycle. The
strength-to-mass ratio
for the
launcher
is
within
the
range attainable
by
boron-fila-
ment
technology:
An
aluminum matrix
containing boron grown
on
tungsten cores
is
calculated
to
have
a
yield stress
of
322 000 psi and
average density
4.1, so
that
p/T
= 135 X
10~
6
Here
p is the
density
and
fthe tension
in
MKS
units.
For
uniform
stress,
the
ratio
of arm
radii
at the
base
and the tip (r, and
r
2
)is
log
rjr,
=
(p/47V
where
v is the
escape
velocity.
For
r-
[
/r
2
less than
50,
pi
T
must
be
less than
2.08
X 10"
6
.
first colony it is probably best to choose
a particular point on that sphere, within
easy range of both Earth and Moon, not
so close as to be eclipsed often, and
preferably stable against displacements
in all three coordinates. The
L4
and
L5
Lagrange
libration
points satisfy all
these conditions. They have the fur-
ther advantage of forming only a very
shallow effective-potential well.
11
Earth, Moon, Sun and the colony
form a restricted four-body gravita-
tional problem, for which the full
solu-.
tion has only been worked out within
the past several years.
12
The stable
motion is a quasielliptical orbit, of large
dimensions, about L5. The maximum
excursions in arc and radius are several
tenths of the Earth-Moon distance.
On the stable orbit there is room for
several thousand colonies; a long time
will pass before colonization can fill so
big an orbit.
Cost minimization
There are several key problems in-
volved here, each of which appears to
yield to an efficient solution in princi-
ple:
reducing freight-shipment cost
from the Earth to L5, the colony site;
minimizing the mass needed from
Earth; designing a device for low-cost
transfer of materials from the Moon to
L
5
.
The first problem was considered by
Robert Wilson (NASA), Eric Hannah
and George Hazelrigg (Princeton) at a
meeting held 9 and 10 May at Princeton
(A Proceedings of this meeting will be
published). Their conclusion was that
the best method during the
1980's
will
probably be conventional chemical
rockets—specifically,
the high-quality
engines already being developed for the
space shuttle. Among several varia-
tions possible, the common feature was
reusability, and the cost estimates for
shipment varied from $190 to $400 per
pound, in 1972 dollars. The cost sum-
mary table (Table 4) therefore assumes
$425 per pound.
To reduce the mass needed from
Earth, most of the repetitive structural
members (aluminum) and window pan-
els (glass) must be produced at
L
5
from
lunar material. A further, important
saving is made by getting 89% of the
mass of needed water from oxygen in
the plentiful lunar-surface oxides,
bringing only 11% of the water mass as
liquid hydrogen from Earth. Of the
500 000-ton total mass (see Table 2) for
the Model 1 colony, 98% can be ob-
tained from the Moon. The elements
most needed are aluminum, titanium,
silicon and oxygen. Lunar surface soil
is usable for agriculture, with the addi-
tion of nitrates and small amounts of
trace elements. The remaining 10 000
tons must come from the Earth.
To bring the total cost within practi-
cal limits, we must develop a low-cost
method for transporting raw materials
from the Moon to the construction site.
The discussion of transport methods
should be taken as an existence proof
rather than as a detailed design. There
may very well be better methods than
those I have considered; however, it is
enough to show two solutions that ap-
pear to be workable. Both use the two
great advantages of the lunar environ-
ment: an excellent vacuum and a very
low escape velocity, about
1.5
miles per
sec,
less than one quarter of the escape
velocity from Earth. To bring a kilo-
gram to
L
5
from the Moon takes less
than 5% of the energy needed to take a
kilogram from Earth.
Both methods assume electric power
from a conventional steam-electric
power plant that uses solar energy, and
both assume that the system runs only
during the lunar day, the night being
used for scheduled maintenance, crew
rest and possibly materials processing.
I have also assumed another factor of
two lost to system breakdowns. Overall
then, each system is assumed to be run-
ning only one week in four.
The first method, called "RPL" for
rotary pellet launcher, is a symmetric,
two-arm propeller-like device, running
at constant speed. (See box on page 38
for description). To transfer 500 tons
in six years, about 26 such RPL's would
be needed, for a total power of 32 MW.
Precise steering is carried out by a lin-
ear electromagnetic deflection-plate
system after the launching, to hold
down the pellet dispersion and permit
easy collection.
The alternative method, called
"TLA" for transport linear accelerator,
uses the technology of dynamic magnet-
ic levitation and the linear synchronous
motor. The TLA is a recirculating sys-
tem of small, passive vehicles (buckets),
each having no moving parts but con-
taining superconducting coils. The
bucket accelerates a 9-kg payload to es-
cape speed along a magnetic-levitation,
linear-synchronous track. Deceleration
then releases the payload, the bucket
slows to a moderate speed, and is recir-
culated to receive another payload.
Table 3 shows some guideline parame-
ters.
The mass estimate is 1500 tons, of
which about 80% is in power-generation
and power-handling equipment. In six
years,
running
25%
of the time, the TLA
can transport over 300 times its own
weight. (For a short bibliography of
early work on the possibilities of elec-
tromagnetic launching, before the de-
velopment of dynamic magnetic levita-
tion, see reference 13.)
Both RPL and TLA may have even-
tual applications as high-throughput,
energetically efficient reaction motors,
running on solar power and able to use
any kind of asteroidal debris as reaction
mass.
They could propel very large
payloads, in the million-ton range or
38 PHYSICS
TODAY/SEPTEMBER
1974