Lead in ancient Rome's city waters

By Delile et al. , 2014

Annotated on Fermat's Library with 13 comments. Text and annotations as Markdown Original paper

The idea that lead is universally recognized as a health hazard is ...
Why measure harbor sediments instead of, say, the pipes themselves ...
Estimating the population of any ancient city is hard - there are n...
In 1983, geochemist Jerome Nriagu published Lead and Lead Poisoning...
**Roman fistulae** The word fistula literally means "tube" in La...
**Defrutum** The "grape juice concoctions prepared in lead cups"...
Lead has four stable isotopes: $^{204}$Pb, $^{206}$Pb, $^{207}$Pb, ...
![](https://i.imgur.com/Fvvcfdt.png) *A diagram depicting the Clau...
Graph A illustrates a "vertical history" of Rome's water system by ...
Graph B translates raw isotope ratios into three geological paramet...
How to read this formula: 
 - The numerator measures how far the r...
This is one of the key conclusions of the paper - while lead isotop...
### Lead mining in the Roman Empire Rome's lead supply came overwh...
Lead in ancient Rome’s city waters
Hugo Delile
a,b,1
, Janne Blichert-Toft
b,c
, Jean-Philippe Goiran
d
, Simon Keay
e
, and Francis Albarède
b,c
a
Université Lumière Lyon 2, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique-Unité Mixte de Recherche (CNRS UMR) 5600, 69676 Bron, Franc e;
b
Ecole Normale
Supérieure de Lyon, Université Claude Bernard Lyon 1, CNRS UMR 5276, 69007 Lyon, France;
c
Department of Earth Science, Rice University, Houston,
TX 77005;
d
Maison de l’Orient et de la Méditerranée, CNRS UMR 5133, 69365 Lyon Cedex 7, France; and
e
Archeology, Faculty of Humanities, University
of Southampton, South ampton SO17 1BF, Great Britain
Edited by Thure E. Cerling, University of Utah, Salt Lake City, UT, and approved March 19, 2014 (received for review January 3, 2014)
It is now universally accepted that utilization of lead for domestic
purposes and water distribution presents a major health hazard.
The ancient Roman world was unaware of these risks. How far the
gigantic network of lead pipes used in ancient Rome compromised
public health in the city is unknown. Lead isotopes in sediments
from the harbor of Imperial Rome register the presence of a strong
anthropogenic component during the beginning of the Common
Era and the Early Middle Ages. They demonstrate that the lead
pipes of the water distribution system increased Pb contents in
drinking water of the capital city by up to two orders of magni-
tude over the natural background. The Pb isotope record shows
that the discontinuities in the pollution of the Tiber by lead are
intimately entwined with the major issues affecting Late Antique
Rome and its water distribution system.
harbor geoarcheology
|
paleopollution
|
Late Holocene
|
ore provenance
|
sedimentology
S
tatistics on demography, money supply and metal circulation,
life and health standards, and many other social parameters
required to understand modern history are largely missing from
the written record of the ancient past. For example, the ap-
parently simple question of how the population of ancient
Rome evolved is still unresolved (1, 2), prompting the design of
indirect estimates (3). Another well-publicized problem illus-
trating the lack of primary sources of accurate information is
the decade-old debate on Pb poisoning of the high society o f
Rome, either by lead water pipes or grape juice concoctions
prepared in l ead cups (4–9). H ere we focus on the condition of
Pb in the public waters of ancient Rome. Lead is regarded as
a powerful and ubiquitous indicator of the manufacturing
status of a society. For example, a surg e in Pb concentrations in
the Greenland ice-core record was correlated with the height
of the Roman Empire (10). Three out of the f our existing Pb
isotopes are rapidly modified by the radioactive decay of nat-
ural uranium or thorium over g eological time. The mini ng of
ores from geologically diverse areas produces metallic Pb with
variable isoto pic abundances that depend on the tectonic age
and the Th/U and U/Pb rati os of th e mining district. Arche-
ologists interested in the provenance of artifacts routinely tap
this wealth of info rmation (11). To explore how the supply of
metals from all over the Roman world and their uti lization may
have affected the nearby environment of ancient Rome, the
present work sets out to investigate the isotope compositions
of Pb in sediment cores from th e Trajanic harbor basin at
Portus, the maritime port of Imperial Rome, and the channel
connecting Portus with the Tiber (Canale Romano) (Fi g. S1).
Harbors are excellent sedimentary traps. The record of human
Pb poll ution from the time that the harbor basi n was excavated
(ca. 112 AD) and well into the Middle Ages offers a new his-
torical, ca. 1,000 y-long perspective on the evolution of Pb
released by Rome, its water distribution system, and the major
disruptive events that affected the life of the capital city and
its harbor.
In 42 AD Claudius started the construction of an open coastal
port to compensate for the long-standing shortcomings of the
existing system for supplying Rome from the Mediterranean,
notably the small scale of the harbor and anchorage facilities at
Ostia and the long route of communication with the principal
maritime port at Puteoli (Pozzuoli) on the Bay of Naples (12).
The inland ∼0.4 km
2
Trajanic basin, which was excavated in the
early years of the second century AD in response to the growing
demands of an expanding population in Rome, offered both
safe mooring to sea-going merchant ships and immense ware-
houses and other buildings (13–15). Communication between the
Claudian and Trajanic basins was facilitated by an entrance
channel, into which the ca. 9-m-long core TR14 was drilled. Up
until the Middle Ages, the Trajanic basin was also accessed from
a man-made branch of the Tiber (Fossa Traiana; what is now the
Fiumicino Canal) by means of the Canale Traverso. The trans-
port of sand and silt sediments from this channel to the Trajanic
Harbor has been attested to by sedimentological, geochemical,
andostracodanalyses(16–18). The now filled-in Canale Romano,
which ran past the southwestern side of the Trajanic basin to-
ward the Tiber, was used to carry cargoes transshipped on to river-
going craft bound for Rome (15). A 13-m-long core labeled CN1
was drilled into the sediments of the Canale Romano. The de-
tailed sedimentology and geochemistry of core TR14 are given
elsewhere together with
14
C ages (18). Some
14
C dates likewise
were obtained for core CN1 (Table S1). For reference and mod-
eling purposes, the bedload of the modern Tiber between Rome
and the Tiber delta was also sampled (Table S2), as were five
different Roman Pb water pipes (fistulæ) collected in Rome and
dating to between the first and the second centuries AD (Fig.
S2). In all, 42 samples from TR14, 37 sam ples from CN1,
6 samples from the Tiber bedload, and 10 samples from the five
Roman fistulæ were measured for their Pb isotope compositions
at the Ecole Normale Supérieure de Lyon.
Significance
Thirty years ago, Jerome Nriagu argued in a milestone paper
that Roman civilization collapsed as a result of lead poisoning.
Clair Patterson, the scientist who convinced governments to
ban lead from gasoline, enthusiastically endorsed this idea,
which nevertheless triggered a volley of publications aimed at
refuting it. Although today lead is no longer seen as the prime
culprit of Rome’s demise, its status in the system of water
distribution by lead pipes (fistulæ) still stands as a major public
health issue. By measuring Pb isotope compositions of sedi-
ments from the Tiber River and the Trajanic Harbor, the present
work shows that “tap water” from ancient Rome had 100 times
more lead than local spring waters.
Author contributions: H.D., J.B.-T., J.-P.G., S.K., and F.A. designed research; H.D., J.B.-T., and
J.-P.G. performed research; J.B.-T. contributed new reagents/analytic tools; H.D. and F.A.
analyzed data; and H.D., J.B.-T., and F.A. wrote the paper.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
This article is a PNAS Direct Submission.
1
To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: hdelile@gmail.com.
This article contains supporting information online at www.pnas.org/lookup/suppl/doi:10.
1073/pnas.1400097111/-/DCSupplemental.
6594–6599
|
PNAS
|
May 6, 2014
|
vol. 111
|
no. 18 www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1400097111
Downloaded from https://www.pnas.org by 23.118.108.61 on April 5, 2026 from IP address 23.118.108.61.
Results and Discussion
The TR14 core can be broken down into successive sedimentary
units corresponding to different time slices: (i) preharbor up to
ca. 100 AD, (ii) Early Empire up to ca. 250 AD, (iii) Late
Empire up to ca. 500 AD, (iv) Early Middle Ages up to ca. 800
AD, and (v) Late Middle Ages (see the “Historical period age-
depth model” columns in Fig. 1). Age boundaries between units
may be uncertain by up to 100 y. Silts and sands dominate sed-
iment mineralogy. The preharbor sequence attests to deposition
in an environment of deltaic progradation (19). The construction
of the harbor brings about a sharp sedimentological change
and marks the beginning of the harbor mud deposits. A well-
stratified ∼50-cm-thick layer within the Early Empire deposits (753
сm) displaying well-preserved shells does not appear in other
cores and may signal local dredging (18, 20). The layer corre-
sponding to the Early Middle Ages contains more carbonates
and ostracods of brackish affinity than the rest of the core. At the
top, the sediments from the Late Middle Ages horizon are
characteristic of flood plain deposits (17, 18).
In Fig. 1, two different representations of lead isotope varia-
tions in TR14 and CN1 have been used: First (Fig. 1A), the
conventional raw isotopic ratios in which
206
Pb is kept as the
denominator; and, second (Fig. 1B), a derived set of geologically
informed parameters which will now be explained. In compliance
Fig. 1. Chronostratigraphic evolution of (A) the raw isotopic ratios of the cores TR14 and CN1 and (B) the geological parameters T
mod
,
238
U/
204
Pb (μ), and
232
Th/
238
U(κ) derived from the raw isotope ratios as described in the main text. The different time slice boundaries (indicated with black arrowheads and
highlighted by alternating light and dark gray shading for better visibility) derived from the age-depth model of core TR14 (18) coincide with major Pb
isotope compositional shifts prominent in both cores. Hercynian Pb shows up during the Early Roman Empire and Early Middle Ages. In contrast, low-Th/U
natural Pb domi nates both the preharbor sequence and the flood plain deposits at the top of TR14.
Delile et al. PNAS
|
May 6, 2014
|
vol. 111
|
no. 18
|
6595
ENVIRONMENTAL
SCIENCES
ANTHROPOLOGY
Downloaded from https://www.pnas.org by 23.118.108.61 on April 5, 2026 from IP address 23.118.108.61.
with literature (e.g., ref. 21), we searched Pb isotope databases
for potential sources of ores matching the Pb isotope composi-
tions of archeological artifacts and sediment samples (Fig. S3).
In addition, the geological province to which a particular Pb
sample belongs can often be inferred from a conversion of its
isotope compositions into a set of geologically informed parame-
ters, the Pb model age T
mod
, and the apparent
238
U/
204
Pb (μ) and
232
Th/
238
U(κ) ratios (e.g., refs. 22–24). T
mod
reflects the tec-
tonic age of the crustal segments in which ore deposits occur. In
Europe, crustal segments of Alpine ages (30–120 Ma) contrast with
Hercynian (240 Ma and older) and early Paleozoic (>450 Ma)
segments . μ and κ are parameters that tend to increase with
crustal depth. Typically, κ is higher in crustal segments that lost
their shallow levels by erosion or tectonic denudation, such as
in Iberia, southern France, and the eastern Alps. Fig. S4 shows
that these parameters can be used to divide Europe into co-
herent regions, which justifies using T
mod
, μ,andκ for provenance
purposes (24–26). T
mod
, μ, and κ in turn provide a rapid char-
acterization of the geological envi ronment in which the ores
formed. Ores formed by remobilization of metal from the un-
derlying basement and hosted in sediments, such as Mississippi
Valley type deposits, may to some extent challenge a simple
interpretation of model ages. Fig. S4 shows, however, that,
overall, the connection between Pb model ages and the tectonic
age of the local crystalline basement remains very strong. The
broad relationship between T
mod
, μ,andκ tectonic provinces is
compelling and holds particularly true for southern Europe (27).
Fig. 2. (A) Lead isotope ratios (
207
Pb/
206
Pb vs.
208
Pb/
206
Pb) and (B) geological parameters (κ vs.
T
mod
) for the leached samples from cores TR14 (red)
and CN1 (blue), the modern Tiber bedload (yellow),
and Rome fistulæ (green). The gray fields corre-
spond to the light and dark gray shaded time slice
bands of Fig. 1 and overlap the samples from core
TR14 in accordance with the respective historical
periods. The two mixing lines (gray dashes) connect,
respectively, α and β on the one hand, and α′ and α″
on the other. The α end-member corresponds to
unpolluted Tiber water and is composed of the
Mediterranean outflow water (α″, blue ellipse) (30)
and volcanic rocks from the Alban Hills (α′ , orange
ellipse) (28, 29). β is the anthropogenic end-
member.
6596
|
www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1400097111 Delile et al.
Downloaded from https://www.pnas.org by 23.118.108.61 on April 5, 2026 from IP address 23.118.108.61.
Principal component analysis of the 3D Pb isotopic data shows
that >99% of the variance is accounted for by two principal
components and, therefore, that the data plot in a plane span-
ning any 3D space of Pb isotopic ratios. Cores TR14 and CN1
define indistinguishable planes, which allows the Pb isotope
data to be merged into a single dataset. As illustrated by the
208
Pb/
206
Pb vs.
207
Pb/
206
Pb pl ot of Fig. 2A, the isotope com-
position of Pb in leachates form two coplanar alignments, which
are most straightforwardly accounted for by the mixing of com-
ponents of different origins.
In Fig. 2 A and B, the component labeled α located at the
intersection (the kink) of the two trends is ubiquitous in both
cores including the preharbor and Late Middle Ages deposits. It
is also an end-member in plots of Pb isotope ratios from leaching
residu es (Fig. S5 A and B). Thi s compone nt therefor e reflects
Pb naturally present in Tiber water. It can itself be broken down
into a mixture of two local low-
207
Pb/
206
Pb sources, the compo-
nent α′ originating from the recent volcanic rocks of the Alban
Hills (28, 29), and the component α″, which is very similar to Pb
dissolved in modern Mediterranean seawater (30) and released
by erosion of recent limestones from the Apennines.
The anthropogenic nature of the third component β becomes
apparent when plotting Al/Pb (data from ref. 18) as a function
of
207
Pb/
206
Pb (Fig. 3). The α−β alignment intersects the x axis at
the value of
207
Pb/
206
Pb of the fistulæ (Al/Pb ≈0), which shows
that the contaminant is essentially pure lead from Al-free and
therefore suspension-free water. As with raw isotopic ratios, a
plot of κ vs. T
mod
(Fig. 2B) shows a bundle of alignments con-
sistent with the observations from isotopic ratios. The alignment
trending toward high
207
Pb/
206
Pb and old model ages reveals that
Pb component β is of Hercynian (or Variscan; T
mod
≈250 Ma)
affinity with rather high κ values. Hercynian Pb is absent from
peninsular Italy, and the Apennines formed less than 20 Ma ago
(31) from recent sediments and volcanic rocks. The Pb component
β therefore, clearly being foreign to peninsular Italy, should
rather be traced to southwestern Spain, the Massif Central of
France, the eastern Alps, Eifel in Germany, the Pennines in Eng-
land, and Macedonia (Fig. S3). Among these potential sources,
only some of them are consistent with the known maritime
freight routes, which are punctuated by frequent shipwrecks
loaded with Pb ingots (32–34), and with the known period and
output of mine exploitation during the Late Republican Period
and the Early Roman Empire (e.g., refs. 21 and 35). An un-
expected observation is the lack of signal from the productive
and geologically young mining areas of the Spanish Betics
(Carthagene). It is most likely that the Pb used for water man-
agement in Rome had been mined in the Spanish Sierra Morena,
the English Pennines, the German Eifel, or the French
Massif Central.
The isotope composition of component β is remarkably con-
sistent with the data on four of the five lead fistulæ analyzed in
this work. Component β is still conspicuous in the leachates from
the modern Tiber bottom sediments, which suggests that to this
day old Pb pollution still permeates the bedload sediment. The
anthropogenic origin of the Hercynian Pb compon ent β is
also attested to by the comparison of leachates and residues:
207
Pb/
206
Pb is, with the sole exception of the deepest sample,
higher in leachates than in residues (Fig. 4). Leaching there-
fore releases older labile Pb from a solid residue of much younger
geological age.
Lead pollution of the Tiber River can be evaluated in a simple
way by using
φ
fist
=
ð
207
Pb=
206
Pb
Þ
riv
−
ð
207
Pb=
206
Pb
Þ
nat
ð
207
Pb
=
206
PbÞ
fist
− ð
207
Pb
=
206
PbÞ
nat
;
where φ
fist
is the fraction of Pb in river water derived from Pb
fistulæ. It has been estimated that the proportion f
fist
of Tiber
water running through the aqueducts was about 3% at the peak
of the Roman Empire (36). It can therefore be deduced that
fistulæ increased Pb in the water distributed in Rome over the
natural level by a factor of about 40, 14, and 105 for the Early
Empire, Late Empire, and High Middle Ages, respectively (SI
Materials and Methods). Although the value of f
fist
is only an
educated guess pertinent to a given period, using different num-
bers does not significantly affect the relative levels of Pb pollu-
tion deduced. These levels are maximum values because they
characterize the final output of the water system to the Tiber
while most Roman citizens would have used drinking water that
was tapped, whether legally or illegally, all along the water distribu-
tion system (36). The inferred increases of Pb in the water of the
Roman distribution system unquestionably attest to general lead
pollution of Roman drinking water but the Pb concentrations at
issue are unlikely to have represented a major health risk (9).
Evidence bearing on the timeline of anthropogenic pollution
in the Rome area can be derived from the sequence of Pb iso-
tope characteristics (Fig. 2). Lead in preharbor sediments is of
Fig. 3. Al/Pb vs.
207
Pb/
206
Pb showing the TR14 (red)
and CN1 (blue) core leachates, the modern Tiber
bedload (yellow), and the Rome fistulæ (green). The
beige field corresponds to the anthropogenic com-
ponent characterized by the fistulæ. Symbols and
parameters are as in Fig. 2. This plot shows that the
Al-free, and therefore suspension-free, water com-
ponent has the same Pb isotope composition as the
fistulæ and therefore corresponds to clear water
from the city water distribution system.
Delile et al. PNAS
|
May 6, 2014
|
vol. 111
|
no. 18
|
6597
ENVIRONMENTAL
SCIENCES
ANTHROPOLOGY
Downloaded from https://www.pnas.org by 23.118.108.61 on April 5, 2026 from IP address 23.118.108.61.
natural origin (trend α′−α″). Excavation of basin deposits dating to
the period of the Early Roman Empire coincides with both a surge
of Hercynian Pb in leachates and a dramatic drop in the isotopic
contrast between the residue and the leachate (trend α–β)(Fig.4).
At this time, the Roman Empire reached the height of its conquests,
especially in western European territor ies such as Britain (Fig.
S3). The isotopic contrast between the fractions rapidly dimin-
ishes, although quite smoothly, from the Early to the Late Ro-
man Imperial perio ds. This ch ange is largely accounted for by
the dramatically smaller contribution of anthropogenic Pb to
leachates and therefore by a lesser pollution of Tiber water. One
interpretation of this may be a redirection of spring wate r away
from the lead pipes of Rome, in some way related to the
controversial decline of the population (3, 37) or to a poorly
documented deterioration of th e water distribution system.
At the end of the Late Roman Empire and throughout the
Early Middle Ages section of TR14, the isotopic difference be-
tween the leachate and the residue bounces back and the pres-
ence of a rather homogenous anthropogenic component rich in
Hercynian Pb again becomes prevalent in leachates (Figs. 2 and
4). The discontinuity appears in both the TR14 and CN1 cores
(Fig. 1). The end of the Early Middle Ages section (∼800 AD) is
also brutal and signals the return of uncontaminated Pb in the
Tiber (trend α′−α″). The persistence of Hercynian Pb in the
bedload of the modern Tiber nevertheless indicates that centu-
ries of contamination, possibly in the form of Pb carbonates, left
a lasting imprint on the river sediments.
The consistency of the Pb isotope results from the CN1 core,
which is expected to carry a straightforward Tiber signal, with those
from the TR14 c ore is rather g ood despite the latter bei ng
susceptible to both harbor activity and input of water from the
Portus aqueduct, which has its source in the vicinity of modern
Ponte Galeria. Both cores reflect the presence of a Hercynian end-
member and coincide on the timing of major isotopic shifts. κ values
in the CN1 core may, however, be marginally higher than those in
TR14, especially during the Early Empire. It is unfortunate that the
Pb isotope database on pipes used for water distribution is still too
limited to identify such small differences with confidence.
The extensive nature of the harbor installations calls for ad-
ditional work beyond the 95 samples of sediment core, bedload,
and Pb pipes from Portus and the Tiber analyzed in this study to
demonstrate unambiguously that the observed discontinuities in
the Pb isotope and overall geochemical record correspond to
catastrophic disruptions of Portus activity. Although the coastal
position of the port leaves the Trajanic basin vulnerable to river
vagaries and maritime hazards, the lack of coarse gravels and
sediment sorting, combined with the good preservation of the
delicate ostracod shells, are strong evidence against exceptional
floods, storms, and tsunamis. The age-depth model (18) is cer-
tainly evocative of some critical dates of Roman history. As
speculated by Delile et al. (18) based on the
14
C record of TR14
and adjacent cores, transitions between units may be correlated
with the initial excavation of the Trajanic basin (by ca. 112 AD),
the continued use of the port during the third century (ca. 250
AD), the gradual fortification and contraction of the port in the
later fifth and earlier sixth centuries (ca. 500 AD), and the
transition to the post-Byzantine period. The later fifth and
sixth century transition is coeval with Belisarius’ fixing of the
decommissioned aqueducts of Rome (38) at the end of the
Gothic Wars (535–554 AD). Byzantine repairs o f the water
distribution system may have remobilized massive amounts of
corrosion products from abandoned lead pipes in which water
may have stagnated for protracted lengths of time. Although a
causal relationship cannot be formally demonstrated, the dis-
continuities in the cores at Portus seem contemporaneous with
historically documented events such as the struggle for the control
of the port between Gothic and Byzantine forces (536–552 AD)
and the damages inflicted to the water distribution system during
the Arab sack of Rome in the mid-ninth century. Further work
is needed to learn whether the causes of Portus’ demise were
natural, with the harbor finally falling into disuse on account of
flood plain deposits, possibly after the major floods of 856 AD
(39–41), or a consequence of military events (39).
Conclusions
This work has shown that the labile fraction of sediments from
Portus and the Tiber bedload attests to pervasive Pb contamination
of river water by the Pb plumbing controlling water distribution
in Rome. Lead pollution of “tap water” in Roman times is clearly
measurable, but unlikely to have been truly harmful. The dis-
continuities punctuating the Pb isotope record provide a strong
background against which ideas about the changing character of
the port can be tested.
Materials and Methods
After removal of the coarse gravel fraction, 500 mg of sample were crushed
and treated with chloroform to remove most of the abundant organic
fraction. The residue was rinsed and leached in dilute HBr. Because lead pipe
corrosion products, such as Pb carbonates (42, 43), were suspected to be
present in the sediments and carry a signal from aqueducts, no attempt was
made at using the more specific protocols developed to selectively extract
hydroxide coatings (e.g., ref. 44). Lead from the leachates was purified on an
ion exchange resin using HBr as eluent of the sample matrix and HCl to elute Pb.
The amounts of Pb extracted were large (>1 μg) and orders of magnitud e
above the blank of the procedure (∼20 pg). Lead isotope compositions were
analyzed by multicollector inductively-coupled plasma mass spectrometry on
both the residues and the leachates of the samples from TR14 and the results
were so systematic that no further attempt was made to also measure the
residues from CN1 (Table S2).
Fig. 4. TR14 downcore behavior of the isotopic contrast (ΔPb isotope ratios)
between the residue and the leachate. Increasing distance from the zero
dashed line (left side of the figure) indicates increasingly predominant an-
thropogenic impact, which is strongest during the Early Roman Empire and
the Early Middle Ages. Time slice model as in Fig. 1.
6598
|
www.pnas.org/cgi/doi/10.1073/pnas.1400097111 Delile et al.
Downloaded from https://www.pnas.org by 23.118.108.61 on April 5, 2026 from IP address 23.118.108.61.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS. We thank the Soprintendenza Speciale per i Beni
Archeologici di Roma: P. Catalano, L. Cianfriglia, A. Pellegrino, L. Vendittelli
(Director of the Crypta Balbi Museum), M. Piranomonte, and Lorenza Manfredi
(Istituto di Studi sulle Civiltà Italiche e del Mediterraneo Antico) for provid-
ing samples of Roman lead pipes from the water distribution system of
ancient Rome. We also thank J.-P. Bravard, J.-C. Domergue, and R. Macchiar-
elli for helpful advice; two anonymous referees for constructive remarks; and
the Institut National des Sciences de l’Univers for suppo rting the analytical
facility at École Normale Supérieure de Lyon and P. Telouk for ensuring that
instruments were always at their best. We acknowledge the Accélérateur
pour la Recherche en sciences de la Terre, Environnement, Muséologie,
Implanté à Saclay program for carrying out the accelerator mass spectrom-
etry radiocarbon dating. We also acknowledge the École Française de Rome,
the British School at Rome, the University of Southampton (The Portus Pro-
ject), the Soprintendenza Speciale per I Beni Archeologici di Roma, the
Young Scientist Program of the Agence Nationale de la Recherche, and
the Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique–Institut des sciences
humaines et sociales/Institut écologie et environnement (Action Interdisci-
plinaire de Recherche Archéométrie and Homere Project) for their financial
and logistical support.
1. Lo Cascio E (1994) The size of the Roman population: Beloch and the meaning of the
Augustan census figures. JRS 84:23–40.
2. Scheidel W (2008) People, Land, and Politics: Demographic Developments and the
Transformation of Roman Italy, 300 BC - AD 14, eds De Light S, Northwood SJ (Brill,
Leiden, The Netherlands), pp 17–70.
3. Turchin P, Scheidel W (2009) Coin hoards speak of population declines in Ancient
Rome. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 106(41):17276–17279.
4. Nriagu JO (1983) Lead and Lead Poisoning in Antiquity (John Wiley & Sons, New York).
5. Hodge AT (1981) Vitruvius, lead pipes and lead poisoning. Am J Archaeol 85(4):
486–491.
6. Scarborough J (1984) The myth of lead poisoning among the Romans: An essay re-
view. J Hist Med Allied Sci 39(4):469–475.
7. Patterson CC, Shirahata H, Ericson JE (1987) Lead in ancient human bones and its
relevance to historical developments of social problems with lead. Sci Total Environ
61:167–200.
8. Aufde rheide AC, et al. (1992) Lead exposure in Italy: 800 BC-700 AD. Int J Anthropol
7(2):9–15.
9. Retief FP, Cilliers L (2006) Lead poisoning in ancient Rome. Acta Theologica 26(2):
147– 164.
10. Hong S, Candelone J-P, Patterson CC, Boutron CF (1994) Greenland ice evidence of
hemispheric lead pollution two millennia ago by Greek and Roman civilizations.
Science 265(5180):1841–1843.
11. Stos-Gale ZA, Gale NH (2009) Metal provenancing using isotopes and the Oxford
archaeological lead isotope database (OXALID). Archaeol Anthropol Sci 1(3):195–213.
12. Goiran J-P, et al. (2014) Geoarchaeology confirms location of the ancient harbour
basin of Ostia (Italy). J Archaeol Sci 41:389–398.
13. Juvenal (1974) Saturae [Satires] (Les Belles Lettres, Paris).
14. Lugli G, Filibeck G (1935) Il po rto di Roma imperi ale e l’agro portuense [ The Harbor
of Imperi al Rome a nd the Ag ro Portuense] (Officine d ell’Istituto Italiano d ’ Ar ti
Grafiche, Rome).
15. Keay S, Millett M, Paroli L, Strutt K (2005) Portus: An Archaeological Survey of the
Port of Imperial Rome (British School at Rome, London).
16. Goiran J-P, et al. (2010) Palaeoenvironmental reconstruction of the ancient harbors of
Rome: Claudius and Trajan’s marine harbors on the Tiber delta. Quat Int 216(1–2):
3–13.
17. Salomon P, Delile H, Goiran J-P, Bravard J-P, Keay S (2012) The Canale di Comunica-
zione Traverso in Portus: The Roman sea harbour under river influence (Tiber Delta,
Italy).
Géomorphologie 1:75–90.
18. Delile H, et al. (2014) Geochemical investigation of a sediment core from the Trajan
basin at Portus, the harbor of ancient Rome. Quat Sci Rev 87:34–45.
19. Bellotti P, et al. (2011) The Tiber river delta plain (central Italy): Coastal evolution and
implications for the ancient Ostia Roman settlement. Holocene 21(7):1105–1116.
20. Sadori L, Giardini M, Giraudi C, Mazzini I (2010) The plant landscape of the imperial
harbour of Rome. J Archaeol Sci 37(12):3294–3305.
21. Bode M, Hauptmann A, Mezger K (2009) Tracing Roman lead sources using lead
isotope analyses in conjunction with archaeological and epigraphic evidence—acase
study from Augustan/Tiberian Germania. Archaeol Anthropol Sci 1(3):177–194.
22. Moorbath S (1962) Lead isotope abundance studies on mineral occurrences in the
British Isles and their geological significance. Phil Trans R Soc A 254(1042):295–360.
23. Pernicka E, Begemann F, Schmitt-Strecker S, Wagner GA (1993) Eneolithic and Early
Bronze Age copper artefacts from the Balkans and their relation to Serbian copper
ores. Prähist Z 68(1):1–54.
24. Albarède F, Desaulty A-M, Blichert-Toft J (2012) A geological perspective on the use
of Pb isotopes in Archaeometry. Archaeometry 54(5):853–867.
25. Desaulty A-M, Telouk P, Albalat E, Albarède F (2011) Isotopic Ag-Cu-Pb record of silver
circulation through 16th-18th century Spain. Pro c Natl Acad Sci USA 108(22):
9002– 9007.
26. Desaulty A-M, Albarede F (2013) Copper, lead, and silver isotopes solve a major
economic conundrum of Tudor and early Stuart Europe. Geology 41(2):135–138.
27. Arribas A, Tosdal RM (1994) Isotopic composition of Pb in ore deposits of the Betic
Cordillera, Spain; origin and r elat ionship to other European deposits. Econ Geol
89(5):1074–1093.
28. Conticelli S, D’Antonio M, Pinarelli L, Civetta L (2002) Source contamination and
mantle heterogeneity in the genesis of Italian potassic and ultrapotassic volcanic
rocks: Sr–Nd–Pb isotope data from Roman Province and Southern Tuscany. Mineral
Petrol 74(2–4):189–222.
29. D’Antonio M, Tilton GR, Civetta L (1996) Petrogenesis of Italian alkaline lavas deduced
from Pb-Sr- Nd isotope r elatio nships . Earth Process es: Reading the Isotopic C ode,
Monograph Series, eds Basu A, Hart S (American Geophysical Union, Washingt on),
pp 253–267.
30. Stumpf R, Frank M, Schönfeld J, Haley BA (2010) Late Quaternary variability of
Mediterranean Outflow Water from radiogenic Nd and Pb isotopes. Quat Sci Rev
29(19
–20):2462–2472.
31. Faccenna C, Becker TW, Lucente FP, Jolivet L, Rossetti F (2001) History of subduction
and back-arc extension in the Central Mediterranean. Geophys J Int 145(3):809–820.
32. Domergue C, Quarati P, Nesta A, Obejero G, Trincherini PR (2012) Les isotopes du
plomb et l’i dentificati on d es lin gots de p lomb romains des mines de Sierra Morena.
Questions de méthode: l’exemple des lingots de l’ épave Cabrera 4. Pallas 90:
243– 256.
33. Brown HG (2011) A study of lead ingot cargoes from ancient Mediterranean ship-
wrecks. MA dissertation (Texas A&M Univ, College Station, TX).
34. Robinson D, Wilson A, eds (2011) Maritime Archaeology and Ancient Trade in the
Mediterranean (Oxford Centre for Maritime Archaeology, Oxford).
35. Domergue C (2008) Les mines antiques: La production des métaux aux époques
grecque et romaine [Ancient Mines: Metal Production During the Greek and Roman
Eras] (Picard, Paris).
36. Blackman DR, Hodge AT (2001) Frontinus’ Legacy (Univ of Michigan Press, Ann Arbor, MI).
37. Lo Cascio E (2001) La population [The population]. Pallas 55:179–198.
38. Procopius History of the Wars, trans Dewing HB, Heinemann W (1962) (Harvard Univ
Press, Cambridge, MA).
39. Duchesne L (1955) Le Liber pontificalis: Texte, introduction et commentaire [The Liber
Pontificalis: Text, Introduction, and Commentary], ed Vogel C (E. de Boccard, Paris).
40. Lanciani R (1899) The destruction of ancient Rome (The Macmillan Company, New York).
41. Keay SJ (2011) Portus and Its Hinterland: Recent Archaeological Research, ed Paroli L
(British School at Rome, London).
42. Grimes SM, Johnston SR, Batchelder DN (1995) Lead carbonate–phosphate system:
Solid–dilute solution exchange reactions in aqueous systems. Analyst (Lond) 120(11):
2741–2746.
43. Peters NJ, Davidson CM, Britton A, Robertson SJ (1999) The nature of corrosion
products in lead pipes used to supply drinking water to the City of Glasgow, Scotland,
UK. Fresenius’. J Anal Chem 363(5–6):562–565.
44. Bayon G, et al. (2002) An improved method for extracting marine sediment fractions
and its application to Sr and Nd isotopic analysis. Chem Geol 187(3–4):179–199.
Delile et al. PNAS
|
May 6, 2014
|
vol. 111
|
no. 18
|
6599
ENVIRONMENTAL
SCIENCES
ANTHROPOLOGY
Downloaded from https://www.pnas.org by 23.118.108.61 on April 5, 2026 from IP address 23.118.108.61.

Discussion

Tap the paper where you want to comment
The idea that lead is universally recognized as a health hazard is remarkably recent. It wasn't until 1978 that the United States banned lead-based paint, and leaded gasoline was only fully phased out in the US in 1996. The scientist most responsible for that ban, Clair Patterson, spent decades fighting the lead industry after discovering that modern humans carried ~100x the lead burden of preindustrial ancestors. Patterson is also a key figure in the intellectual lineage of this paper - he co-authored the landmark 1994 study that found Roman-era lead pollution preserved in Greenland ice cores, and his framework of comparing "natural" vs. "anthropogenic" lead is exactly the approach Delile et al. use here with their $\alpha$ (natural) and $\beta$ (anthropogenic) isotopic components. The Romans themselves were not entirely unaware. Vitruvius (Roman engineer from the 1st century BC), warned that lead pipes made water harmful and recommended clay instead, noting that plumbers had a pallid complexion from daily lead exposure. His advice was largely ignored - lead was cheaper, more durable, and easier to shape. Why measure harbor sediments instead of, say, the pipes themselves or ancient bones? Harbors are natural sediment traps - fine particles settle in the calm, enclosed water and accumulate in undisturbed layers, creating a continuous geological archive. Each layer records the chemistry of the water at the time it was deposited. Portus, the main maritime port of imperial Rome, is especially well-suited because its enclosed Trajanic basin, a hexagonal artificial lake, acted like a giant settling pond, trapping fine silt carried by the Tiber and its canals for over a millennium. ![](https://i.imgur.com/5O0PHVZ.png) *Map of the Portus* ![](https://i.imgur.com/aHpNJeT.png) *Trajanic Basin* Estimating the population of any ancient city is hard - there are no reliable bureaucratic records that survive intact. Rome did conduct censuses, but the three Augustan counts (28 BC, 8 BC, and 14 AD) recorded ~4–5 million citizens, and scholars still disagree about whether they counted all citizens or only adult males. That single interpretive question shifts estimates of the entire Empire's population from ~50 million to ~80 million. Indirect methods - calculating from grain import volumes, urban footprint area, or soldier-to-population ratios - each come with their own assumptions. For the city of Rome itself, most estimates converge on roughly 800,000–1,000,000 at its 1st–2nd century peak. In 1983, geochemist Jerome Nriagu published Lead and Lead Poisoning in Antiquity, arguing that chronic lead exposure - from water pipes (fistulae), wine sweetened with lead-acetate syrup (defrutum), and lead-glazed cookware - contributed to the fall of the Roman Empire by causing widespread infertility, mental illness, and gout among the ruling class. The thesis drew heavy criticism. Scarborough (1984) called it a "myth," noting that Romans were partly aware of lead's dangers — Vitruvius (1st c. BC) already recommended clay pipes over lead ones. Hodge (1981) pointed out that calcium carbonate deposits would have quickly lined the inside of lead pipes, limiting dissolution. Modern bone analyses (Aufderheide et al., 1992) confirmed elevated lead levels in Roman skeletal remains, but not at concentrations that would explain societal collapse. The current consensus: Romans were certainly exposed to harmful lead levels, but lead was one stressor among many - not the singular cause of Rome's decline. **Defrutum** The "grape juice concoctions prepared in lead cups" the authors refer to is defrutum - a Roman sweetener made by boiling grape must down to a thick syrup, typically in lead or lead-lined bronze vessels. This would form lead acetate - known as "sugar of lead" for its intensely sweet taste. Romans used defrutum liberally: as a wine preservative, a sauce base, and even a food condiment. Pliny the Elder specifically recommended using lead vessels over copper ones for the preparation, inadvertently maximizing contamination. Alongside with lead pipes discussed in this paper, defrutum was the other major suspected vector of lead ingestion in Roman daily life. Lead has four stable isotopes: $^{204}$Pb, $^{206}$Pb, $^{207}$Pb, and $^{208}$Pb. While $^{204}\text{Pb}$ is "primordial" - meaning its abundance has remained constant since the Earth formed = the other three are "radiogenic". They are continuously produced by the slow radioactive decay of uranium ($U$) and thorium ($Th$) over millions of years: $$^{238}\text{U} \rightarrow {}^{206}\text{Pb}$$
$$^{235}\text{U} \rightarrow {}^{207}\text{Pb}$$ 
$$^{232}\text{Th} \rightarrow {}^{208}\text{Pb}$$
 Because different mining regions across the Roman Empire have distinct geological ages and initial concentrations of $U$ and $Th$, the lead extracted from them carries a unique isotopic fingerprint. Older crustal segments, such as the Hercynian belts in Southwest Spain or Britain (250 Million years old) exhibit significantly different isotopic ratios than the younger Alpine segments of Italy (20 Million years old). This is what makes lead isotopes so powerful for provenance work: every mining district leaves a characteristic isotopic fingerprint in the metal it produces. By measuring the isotope ratios in a Roman pipe or a harbor sediment, one can work backward to identify where the lead was originally mined. ![](https://i.imgur.com/Fvvcfdt.png) *A diagram depicting the Claudian basin* **Roman fistulae** The word fistula literally means "tube" in Latin. Roman lead pipes were made by casting flat lead sheets, bending them around a wooden cylinder, and soldering the seam. Frontinus, Rome's water commissioner (~97 AD), catalogued fifteen standardized sizes. Pipes were often stamped with the owner's or emperor's name, making them useful archaeological artifacts. Fistulae became widespread from the 1st century BC as Rome's aqueduct network expanded - at its peak roughly 400 km of aqueducts fed into a vast distribution system serving fountains, baths, and private homes. Use declined from the 5th century AD as Gothic sieges and population loss left aqueducts in disrepair. ![](https://i.imgur.com/oWyRCJk.png) *Fistulae* Graph A illustrates a "vertical history" of Rome's water system by tracking lead isotope ratios in two sediment cores: TR14 (harbor basin) and CN1 (river channel). - **The Vertical Axis (Depth)**: Represents time. The deeper the sediment, the further back in history. The layers transition from the Pre-harbor era (bottom) through the Roman Empire and into the Middle Ages (top). - **Pink vs. Blue (The Pollution Signal)**: - Pink Shading: Indicates "natural" lead levels. This is the baseline from local Italian rocks eroded by the Tiber before and after the peak of Roman plumbing. - Blue Shading: Highlights "anthropogenic" (human-caused) lead. These "bulges" appear when lead from the city's massive network of fistulae (pipes) washed into the river and settled in the harbor. - **The Two Peaks**: Notice the distinct blue shifts during the Early Roman Empire (the height of the aqueducts) and again during the Early Middle Ages. The latter likely reflects massive repairs to the water system by the Byzantines, which remobilized centuries of lead corrosion into the "tap water" Graph B translates raw isotope ratios into three geological parameters that act as a "GPS" for identifying where Rome’s lead was mined. By comparing these to known ore deposits, researchers proved the lead in the harbor was "anthropogenic" (man-made pollution) and not from local Italian soil. - $\text{T}_{mod}$ (Model Age in Millions of years): This indicates the tectonic age of the Earth's crust where the lead formed. The "natural" lead in the Tiber is young ($<20$ Ma), but the peaks in the core shift toward 250 Ma, pointing to ancient "Hercynian" ores from regions like Spain, Britain, or Germany.
 - $\mu$ (Mu): This is the ratio of $^{238}\text{U}/^{204}\text{Pb}$ in the source rock. It typically increases with crustal depth and helps distinguish between different mining districts that might have similar ages. - $\kappa$ (Kappa): This represents the $^{232}\text{Th}/^{238}\text{U}$ ratio. High $\kappa$ values ($>3.95$) are a signature of the imported lead used in Roman fistulae.
 Why $\mu$ and $\kappa$ are relevant: While age ($\text{T}_{mod}$) is helpful, many different places on Earth have 250-million-year-old rocks. Adding $\mu$ and $\kappa$ creates a multi-dimensional "fingerprint". This allowed the researchers to rule out local volcanic sources from the Alban Hills and confirm that the lead perfectly matches the chemical signature of actual Roman water pipes found in the city. ### Lead mining in the Roman Empire Rome's lead supply came overwhelmingly from silver mining. Most lead ores are galena (PbS), a dense, metallic-gray mineral that often contains small amounts of silver. Smelting separated the silver, the real prize, from the lead, which was treated as a lucrative byproduct. This meant lead was cheap and abundant: estimates suggest the Empire produced around 80,000 tonnes of lead per year at its peak, a level not matched again until the Industrial Revolution. Major mining districts included the Sierra Morena in southern Spain (the largest source), the Mendip Hills and Pennines in Britain, the Eifel in Germany, and the Massif Central in France. Mines were state property, operated either directly by imperial agents or leased to private contractors (conductores) who used a mix of free labor, slaves, and convicts. Conditions were brutal; Pliny and Strabo both describe the toll on miners. Lead was cast into standardized ingots (typically ~70–90 kg) stamped with the emperor's name, the mining district, and sometimes the lessee. These ingots traveled by ship along well-established maritime routes; dozens of Roman shipwrecks loaded with lead ingots have been found across the Mediterranean. Once in Rome, lead was used for pipes, roofing, tank linings, coffins, curse tablets, sling bullets, and of course defrutum vessels. Its versatility and low cost made it the Roman equivalent of plastic. ![](https://i.imgur.com/uI0WRzt.jpeg)
*Roman mine depiction* How to read this formula: 
 - The numerator measures how far the river water shifted away from its natural state. - The denominator measures the total possible distance between pure natural lead and pure pipe lead. By dividing them, you get a percentage of the lead that came from human pollution. This is one of the key conclusions of the paper - while lead isotopes confirm that Roman "tap water" had up to 100 times more lead than local springs , this pollution likely wasn't a primary cause of the Empire's collapse.